Do You Capture a Sound — or Synthesize It?

When making music, there’s a deceptively simple question hiding at the heart of every track:

Do you record a sound that already exists — or do you create one from scratch?

Both approaches are powerful. Both are creative. And increasingly, most modern music lives somewhere between the two.

---

🎻 Capturing Sound: Freezing a Moment in Time

Recording an instrument is about documentation with intent.

• A violin bow biting the string

• Breath noise at the start of a flute note

• Hammer thump and pedal creak on a piano

• Room reflections colouring the tone

These imperfections aren’t flaws — they’re information. They tell the listener that a human, in a real space, made this sound at this moment.

Capturing sound is about:

• Performance

• Expression

• Acoustics

• Irreproducibility

Play the same note twice and it’s never quite the same. That’s the magic.

---

🔊 Synthesising Sound: Designing the Impossible

Synthesis flips the question around.

Instead of “How did this sound happen?”
It asks “What could sound like this?”

Oscillators, filters, envelopes and modulation let you:

• Create instruments that never existed

• Stretch time, pitch and timbre beyond physics

• Build sounds that evolve, breathe and morph

Synthesis excels at:

• Precision

• Repeatability

• Exploration

• Control

A sound can be rebuilt, reshaped, automated and recalled exactly — every time.

---

🔁 The Modern Reality: Hybrid Everything

Most music today isn’t either/or — it’s both.

• A recorded piano layered with a soft synth pad

• A sampled string note stretched and re-filtered

• A synth bass re-amped through a speaker and mic’d

• Acoustic drums reinforced with synthetic transients

The boundary between recording and sound design has quietly dissolved.

---

🎧 So… Which Is Better?

That’s like asking whether:

• A camera is better than a paintbrush

• A microscope is better than a telescope

They answer different questions.

• Capture sound when you want human presence

• Synthesize sound when you want sonic imagination

• Combine them when you want something genuinely new

---

Final Thought

Music isn’t about choosing sides.
It’s about choosing tools that serve the idea.

Sometimes the right answer is a microphone.
Sometimes it’s an oscillator.
Very often, it’s both — working together.